Gorgias and the justice of tragic apatē -- The circulation and significance of apatē in the Classical era in the Classical era -- The dramatic entanglement of aesthetic illusion with deceit in Sophocles' Electra -- Immersion and corruption in Plato's Republic -- The void of Hellenistic criticism -- The appeal and challenge of apatē in Imperial criticism: Plutarch's De audiendis poetis -- Lucian and the spell of philosophy -- How to read ekphrasis: Tabula Cebetis -- Christian polemics against idolatry: Clement of Alexandria's Protrepticus -- The aesthetics of deception reconfigured in Heliodorus' Ethiopica -- From deep-fake to psychotherapy: The aesthetics of deception today