Staff view for An Organizing Framework for Teaching Practices that Can “Expand” the Self and Address Social Identity Concerns

cdi_proquest_journals_2758460293

Document Data

	--- !ruby/object:Document::ArticleItem::General
data:
  pnx:
    addata:
      orcidid:
      - https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5050-706X
      abstract:
      - |-
        The contributed papers in this special issue each provide valuable perspectives on how social processes are relevant to academic motivation. Yet a critical question remains: How can this research lead to concrete guidance for educators who wish to create motivating and equitable classrooms? We propose this complex task can be simplified by encouraging educators to address students’ concerns about how they are viewed by instructors in school. Our review of the literature suggests that two meta-concerns are particularly important to address for students from groups marginalized in education: whether instructors may (1) see them as limited in academic potential and (2) narrowly define them by their academic success. We argue that effective teaching practices address these concerns by communicating two corresponding messages: (1)
        inclusive expectations
        , “I recognize your potential for academic growth” and (2)
        broad regard
        , “I regard you as a whole person, with a range of personal values, social identities, and relationships
        .
        ” These messages can shift students away from a “narrow” sense of self, in which their value is defined by current academic performance, and towards an “expansive” sense of self, in which students feel both academically capable and valued for more than just their academic success. We present evidence that novice instructors can use this framework to develop or adapt practices that are attuned to marginalized students’ two meta-concerns and enhance student motivation and engagement. Throughout this commentary, we describe how this framework can build on the important theoretical advances presented elsewhere in this special issue.
      issn:
      - 1040-726X
      au:
      - Smith, Eric N.
      - Yeager, David S.
      - Dweck, Carol S.
      - Walton, Gregory M.
      atitle:
      - An Organizing Framework for Teaching Practices that Can “Expand” the Self
        and Address Social Identity Concerns
      jtitle:
      - Educational psychology review
      stitle:
      - Educ Psychol Rev
      date:
      - '2022-12-01'
      risdate:
      - '2022'
      volume:
      - '34'
      issue:
      - '4'
      spage:
      - '2197'
      epage:
      - '2219'
      pages:
      - 2197-2219
      eissn:
      - 1573-336X
      genre:
      - article
      ristype:
      - JOUR
      cop:
      - New York
      pub:
      - Springer US
      doi:
      - 10.1007/s10648-022-09715-z
      format:
      - journal
    search:
      title:
      - An Organizing Framework for Teaching Practices that Can “Expand” the Self
        and Address Social Identity Concerns
      - Educational psychology review
      creator:
      - Smith, Eric N.
      - Yeager, David S.
      - Dweck, Carol S.
      - Walton, Gregory M.
      creationdate:
      - '2022'
      subject:
      - Academic achievement
      - Child and School Psychology
      - Computer Assisted Instruction
      - Education
      - Educational Psychology
      - Instructional Effectiveness
      - Learning and Instruction
      - Literature reviews
      - Marginality
      - Minority groups
      - Motivation
      - Review Article
      - Social identity
      - Social processes
      - Social values
      - Student Motivation
      - Students
      - Teacher Effectiveness
      - Teachers
      - Teaching
      - Teaching Methods
      recordtype:
      - article
      sourceid:
      - BHHNA
      recordid:
      - eNp9kc1qGzEUhUVoIanbF-hK0PW4-hmNNEtj4jZgSCEJeCc0mitHqS250pgmXuVBkpfLk1TOFLILWlzpcL6rezkIfaVkSgmR3zMlTa0qwlhFWklFdThBZ1RIXnHerD6UO6lJJVmzOkWfcr4jpNhqfobSLODLtDbBH3xY40UyW_gb02_sYsLXYOztUf6VjB28hYyHWzPguQn45fHp_H5nQv_y-FxUwFewcbi88azvE-SMr6L1ZoMvegiDHx7wPAYLKeTP6KMzmwxf_tcJulmcX89_VsvLHxfz2bKyTKmhErLsAa5rGRWu67tedLaF2tC2t4oxrqxRpmkYZUp2pDa1ZIJQSYG6Vglh-AR9G_vuUvyzhzzou7hPoXypmRSqbghreXFNR9fabED74OJQli2nh623MYDzRZ9JTmvBeSEmiI2ATTHnBE7vkt-a9KAp0ccw9BiGLmHo1zD0oUB8hHIxhzWkt1neof4BsIKOzQ
      orcidid:
      - https://orcid.org/0000-0001-5050-706X
      creatorcontrib:
      - Smith, Eric N.
      - Yeager, David S.
      - Dweck, Carol S.
      - Walton, Gregory M.
      startdate:
      - '20221201'
      enddate:
      - '20221201'
      scope:
      - AAYXX
      - CITATION
      - 0-V
      - 3V.
      - 7U4
      - 7XB
      - 88B
      - 88G
      - 8A4
      - 8FI
      - 8FJ
      - 8FK
      - ABUWG
      - AFKRA
      - ALSLI
      - AZQEC
      - BENPR
      - BHHNA
      - CCPQU
      - CJNVE
      - DWI
      - DWQXO
      - FYUFA
      - GHDGH
      - GNUQQ
      - M0P
      - M2M
      - PQEDU
      - PQEST
      - PQQKQ
      - PQUKI
      - PRINS
      - PSYQQ
      - Q9U
      - WZK
      issn:
      - 1040-726X
      - 1573-336X
      fulltext:
      - 'true'
      addtitle:
      - Educ Psychol Rev
      general:
      - Springer US
      - Springer
      - Springer Nature B.V
      rsrctype:
      - article
      description:
      - |-
        The contributed papers in this special issue each provide valuable perspectives on how social processes are relevant to academic motivation. Yet a critical question remains: How can this research lead to concrete guidance for educators who wish to create motivating and equitable classrooms? We propose this complex task can be simplified by encouraging educators to address students’ concerns about how they are viewed by instructors in school. Our review of the literature suggests that two meta-concerns are particularly important to address for students from groups marginalized in education: whether instructors may (1) see them as limited in academic potential and (2) narrowly define them by their academic success. We argue that effective teaching practices address these concerns by communicating two corresponding messages: (1)
        inclusive expectations
        , “I recognize your potential for academic growth” and (2)
        broad regard
        , “I regard you as a whole person, with a range of personal values, social identities, and relationships
        .
        ” These messages can shift students away from a “narrow” sense of self, in which their value is defined by current academic performance, and towards an “expansive” sense of self, in which students feel both academically capable and valued for more than just their academic success. We present evidence that novice instructors can use this framework to develop or adapt practices that are attuned to marginalized students’ two meta-concerns and enhance student motivation and engagement. Throughout this commentary, we describe how this framework can build on the important theoretical advances presented elsewhere in this special issue.
    delivery:
      fulltext:
      - fulltext
      delcategory:
      - Remote Search Resource
    display:
      title:
      - An Organizing Framework for Teaching Practices that Can “Expand” the Self
        and Address Social Identity Concerns
      source:
      - EBSCOhost Professional Development Collection
      - SpringerLINK Contemporary (BTAA)
      - EBSCOhost Education Research Complete
      - Sociological Abstracts
      - EBSCOhost Academic Search Premier
      creator:
      - Smith, Eric N. ; Yeager, David S. ; Dweck, Carol S. ; Walton, Gregory M.
      publisher:
      - 'New York: Springer US'
      ispartof:
      - Educational psychology review, 2022-12, Vol.34 (4), p.2197-2219
      identifier:
      - 'ISSN: 1040-726X'
      - 'EISSN: 1573-336X'
      - 'DOI: 10.1007/s10648-022-09715-z'
      subject:
      - Academic achievement ; Child and School Psychology ; Computer Assisted Instruction
        ; Education ; Educational Psychology ; Instructional Effectiveness ; Learning
        and Instruction ; Literature reviews ; Marginality ; Minority groups ; Motivation
        ; Review Article ; Social identity ; Social processes ; Social values ; Student
        Motivation ; Students ; Teacher Effectiveness ; Teachers ; Teaching ; Teaching
        Methods
      language:
      - eng
      rights:
      - The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer Science+Business Media,
        LLC, part of Springer Nature 2022. Springer Nature or its licensor (e.g. a
        society or other partner) holds exclusive rights to this article under a publishing
        agreement with the author(s) or other rightsholder(s); author self-archiving
        of the accepted manuscript version of this article is solely governed by the
        terms of such publishing agreement and applicable law.
      - COPYRIGHT 2022 Springer
      type:
      - article
      lds50:
      - peer_reviewed
      description:
      - |-
        The contributed papers in this special issue each provide valuable perspectives on how social processes are relevant to academic motivation. Yet a critical question remains: How can this research lead to concrete guidance for educators who wish to create motivating and equitable classrooms? We propose this complex task can be simplified by encouraging educators to address students’ concerns about how they are viewed by instructors in school. Our review of the literature suggests that two meta-concerns are particularly important to address for students from groups marginalized in education: whether instructors may (1) see them as limited in academic potential and (2) narrowly define them by their academic success. We argue that effective teaching practices address these concerns by communicating two corresponding messages: (1)
        inclusive expectations
        , “I recognize your potential for academic growth” and (2)
        broad regard
        , “I regard you as a whole person, with a range of personal values, social identities, and relationships
        .
        ” These messages can shift students away from a “narrow” sense of self, in which their value is defined by current academic performance, and towards an “expansive” sense of self, in which students feel both academically capable and valued for more than just their academic success. We present evidence that novice instructors can use this framework to develop or adapt practices that are attuned to marginalized students’ two meta-concerns and enhance student motivation and engagement. Throughout this commentary, we describe how this framework can build on the important theoretical advances presented elsewhere in this special issue.
    links:
      thumbnail:
      - "$$Tsyndetics_thumb_exl"
      openurl:
      - "$$Topenurl_article"
      linktopdf:
      - "$$Uhttps://link.springer.com/content/pdf/10.1007/s10648-022-09715-z$$EPDF$$P50$$Gspringer$$H"
      linktohtml:
      - "$$Uhttps://link.springer.com/10.1007/s10648-022-09715-z$$EHTML$$P50$$Gspringer$$H"
      openurlfulltext:
      - "$$Topenurlfull_article"
    facets:
      creationdate:
      - '2022'
      language:
      - eng
      creatorcontrib:
      - Smith, Eric N.
      - Yeager, David S.
      - Dweck, Carol S.
      - Walton, Gregory M.
      rsrctype:
      - articles
      jtitle:
      - Educational psychology review
      prefilter:
      - articles
      collection:
      - CrossRef
      - ProQuest Social Sciences Premium Collection【Remote access available】
      - ProQuest Central (Corporate)
      - Sociological Abstracts (pre-2017)
      - ProQuest Central (purchase pre-March 2016)
      - Education Database (Alumni Edition)
      - Psychology Database (Alumni)
      - Education Periodicals
      - Hospital Premium Collection
      - Hospital Premium Collection (Alumni Edition)
      - ProQuest Central (Alumni) (purchase pre-March 2016)
      - ProQuest Central (Alumni)
      - ProQuest Central
      - Social Science Premium Collection
      - ProQuest Central Essentials
      - ProQuest Central
      - Sociological Abstracts
      - ProQuest One Community College
      - Education Collection
      - Sociological Abstracts
      - ProQuest Central
      - Health Research Premium Collection
      - Health Research Premium Collection (Alumni)
      - ProQuest Central Student
      - Education Database
      - Psychology Database
      - ProQuest One Education
      - ProQuest One Academic Eastern Edition (DO NOT USE)
      - ProQuest One Academic
      - ProQuest One Academic UKI Edition
      - ProQuest Central China
      - ProQuest One Psychology
      - ProQuest Central Basic
      - Sociological Abstracts (Ovid)
      toplevel:
      - peer_reviewed
      - online_resources
      topic:
      - Academic achievement
      - Child and School Psychology
      - Computer Assisted Instruction
      - Education
      - Educational Psychology
      - Instructional Effectiveness
      - Learning and Instruction
      - Literature reviews
      - Marginality
      - Minority groups
      - Motivation
      - Review Article
      - Social identity
      - Social processes
      - Social values
      - Student Motivation
      - Students
      - Teacher Effectiveness
      - Teachers
      - Teaching
      - Teaching Methods
      frbrgroupid:
      - cdi_FETCH-LOGICAL-c288t-57715efb9215fbdbd5bc9e4a19dc82238ca8a6621287b04a47250171e1f9855a3
      frbrtype:
      - '5'
    sort:
      title:
      - An Organizing Framework for Teaching Practices that Can “Expand” the Self
        and Address Social Identity Concerns
      creationdate:
      - '20221201'
      author:
      - Smith, Eric N. ; Yeager, David S. ; Dweck, Carol S. ; Walton, Gregory M.
    control:
      iscdi:
      - 'true'
      originalsourceid:
      - FETCH-LOGICAL-c288t-57715efb9215fbdbd5bc9e4a19dc82238ca8a6621287b04a47250171e1f9855a3
      recordtype:
      - article
      addsrcrecordid:
      - eNp9kc1qGzEUhUVoIanbF-hK0PW4-hmNNEtj4jZgSCEJeCc0mitHqS250pgmXuVBkpfLk1TOFLILWlzpcL6rezkIfaVkSgmR3zMlTa0qwlhFWklFdThBZ1RIXnHerD6UO6lJJVmzOkWfcr4jpNhqfobSLODLtDbBH3xY40UyW_gb02_sYsLXYOztUf6VjB28hYyHWzPguQn45fHp_H5nQv_y-FxUwFewcbi88azvE-SMr6L1ZoMvegiDHx7wPAYLKeTP6KMzmwxf_tcJulmcX89_VsvLHxfz2bKyTKmhErLsAa5rGRWu67tedLaF2tC2t4oxrqxRpmkYZUp2pDa1ZIJQSYG6Vglh-AR9G_vuUvyzhzzou7hPoXypmRSqbghreXFNR9fabED74OJQli2nh623MYDzRZ9JTmvBeSEmiI2ATTHnBE7vkt-a9KAp0ccw9BiGLmHo1zD0oUB8hHIxhzWkt1neof4BsIKOzQ
      sourcetype:
      - Aggregation Database
      sourceformat:
      - XML
      sourcesystem:
      - Other
      pqid:
      - '2758460293'
      galeid:
      - A731453329
      sourceid:
      - gale_proqu
      recordid:
      - cdi_proquest_journals_2758460293
      sourcerecordid:
      - A731453329
      score:
      - '0.002654939'
  delivery:
    link: []
    deliveryCategory:
    - Remote Search Resource
    availability:
    - fulltext
    displayLocation: false
    additionalLocations: false
    physicalItemTextCodes: ''
    feDisplayOtherLocations: false
    displayedAvailability: 'true'
    holding: []
    almaOpenurl: https://na02.alma.exlibrisgroup.com/view/uresolver/01UWI_MAD/openurl?ctx_enc=info:ofi/enc:UTF-8&ctx_id=10_1&ctx_tim=2024-07-27
      07:25:05&ctx_ver=Z39.88-2004&url_ctx_fmt=info:ofi/fmt:kev:mtx:ctx&url_ver=Z39.88-2004&rfr_id=info:sid/primo.exlibrisgroup.com-gale_proqu&rft_val_fmt=info:ofi/fmt:kev:mtx:journal&rft.genre=article&rft.atitle=An+Organizing+Framework+for+Teaching+Practices+that+Can+%E2%80%9CExpand%E2%80%9D+the+Self+and+Address+Social+Identity+Concerns&rft.jtitle=Educational+psychology+review&rft.au=Smith%2C+Eric+N.&rft.date=2022-12-01&rft.volume=34&rft.issue=4&rft.spage=2197&rft.epage=2219&rft.pages=2197-2219&rft.issn=1040-726X&rft.eissn=1573-336X&rft_id=info:doi/10.1007%2Fs10648-022-09715-z&rft.pub=Springer+US&rft.place=New+York&rft.stitle=Educ+Psychol+Rev&rft_dat=<gale_proqu>A731453329</gale_proqu>&svc_dat=viewit&rft_galeid=A731453329&rft_pqid=2758460293
  context: PC
  adaptor: Primo Central
  extras:
    citationTrails:
      citing:
      - FETCH-LOGICAL-c288t-57715efb9215fbdbd5bc9e4a19dc82238ca8a6621287b04a47250171e1f9855a3
      citedby:
      - FETCH-LOGICAL-c288t-57715efb9215fbdbd5bc9e4a19dc82238ca8a6621287b04a47250171e1f9855a3
    timesCited: {}
  "@id": https://na02.alma.exlibrisgroup.com/primaws/rest/pub/pnxs/PC/cdi_proquest_journals_2758460293

	

Electronic Resources

Full text is available

Proxy will be added to source or direct links

This document needs electronic context lookup (uresolver)

		---
- :service_type: getFullTxt
  :collection_name: EBSCOhost Academic Search Premier
  :coverage_statement: Available from 09/01/1993.<br>Most recent 1 year(s) not available.
  :public_note: ''
  :from_nz: false
  :filtered: false
  :filter_reason: ''
  :direct_link: https://wisconsin-madison.alma.exlibrisgroup.com/view/action/uresolver.do?operation=resolveService&package_service_id=50459204610002122&institutionId=2122&customerId=2120
- :service_type: getFullTxt
  :collection_name: EBSCOhost Education Research Complete
  :coverage_statement: Available from 09/01/1993.<br>Most recent 1 year(s) not available.
  :public_note: ''
  :from_nz: false
  :filtered: false
  :filter_reason: ''
  :direct_link: https://wisconsin-madison.alma.exlibrisgroup.com/view/action/uresolver.do?operation=resolveService&package_service_id=50459204600002122&institutionId=2122&customerId=2120
- :service_type: getFullTxt
  :collection_name: Professional development collection
  :coverage_statement: Available from 09/01/1993.<br>Most recent 1 year(s) not available.
  :public_note: ''
  :from_nz: false
  :filtered: false
  :filter_reason: ''
  :direct_link: https://wisconsin-madison.alma.exlibrisgroup.com/view/action/uresolver.do?operation=resolveService&package_service_id=50459204580002122&institutionId=2122&customerId=2120
- :service_type: getFullTxt
  :collection_name: SpringerLink Journals
  :coverage_statement: 'Available from 1997 issue: 1.'
  :public_note: ''
  :from_nz: false
  :filtered: false
  :filter_reason: ''
  :direct_link: https://wisconsin-madison.alma.exlibrisgroup.com/view/action/uresolver.do?operation=resolveService&package_service_id=50459204570002122&institutionId=2122&customerId=2120