Introduction: a question for President Jefferson -- Judicial review and the constitution -- The first Ohio decision: the cost award cases -- The Ohio Supreme Court hears Rutherford v. M'Fadden -- A moot court argument -- Judicial review challenged: lest we again be marshall'd -- Charles Hammond and The rights of the judiciary -- The judges impeached: the opposing contentions -- The judges tried: proceedings in the Ohio Senate -- The judges deprived: the Sweeping resolution -- The judges defiant: Tod and Sprigg -- Greene County's subversives: Snowden and Huston -- The resolution repealed -- A new constitutional equilibrium